Viewing entries tagged
standa

Comment

Second Circuit Holds Clear-Error Review Still Governs Cancellation Hardship Findings After Urias-Orellana, Denying Petition From Salvadoran Father

In a per curiam opinion, the Second Circuit has denied a petition for review from a Salvadoran national whose application for cancellation of removal, based on hardship to his three U.S.-citizen children, was denied by an Immigration Judge and affirmed by the Board. The court held that the clear-error standard from Toalombo Yanez v. Bondi still governs review of the hardship determination under 8 U.S.C. § 1229b(b)(1)(D), and that the Supreme Court's decision in Urias-Orellana v. Bondi did not displace it. Urias-Orellana addressed persecution determinations in asylum cases, and Al Saidi v. Blanche addressed a torture-based deferral claim; neither involved hardship, and the panel treated Al Saidi's broader statement that substantial-evidence review applies to all mixed questions as dicta.

The court's jurisdiction is limited to constitutional claims and questions of law under 8 U.S.C. § 1252(a)(2)(B)(i) and (a)(2)(D), so challenges to how the Board weighed the evidence were outside it, and it found no clear error in the finding that the hardship was not substantially beyond that ordinarily expected on removal. On the motion to remand based on new evidence of the children's mental health conditions, the court applied the motion-to-reopen standards under Li Yong Cao and found no abuse of discretion, because the Board considered the evidence and the petitioner identified nothing in the record showing treatment is unavailable in El Salvador.

The full text of Diaz v. Blanche can be found here: https://ww3.ca2.uscourts.gov/decisions/OPN/25-2880_opn.pdf

Comment