The First Circuit has determined that a consular post’s determination that a visa applicant was in the F-1 category, rather than an immediate relative, because he was over age 21 when his petitioning father naturalized, is reviewable by a federal court. The Court determined that the petition reclassification does not constitute a visa denial, and thus, does not implicate the doctrine of consular nonreviewability. The First Circuit also agreed with the Ninth Circuit that a beneficiary’s age at the time of a parent’s naturalization refers not to their biological age, but their CSPA-adjusted age. Thus, because the applicant’s CSPA-adjusted age was 20 at the time of his father’s naturalization, he was properly categorized as an immediate relative.
The full text of Teles de Menezes v. Rubio can be found here: https://www.ca1.uscourts.gov/sites/ca1/files/opnfiles/24-1253P-01A.pdf