On remand from the Supreme Court in light of Loper Bright, the Fourth Circuit has granted a petition for review and held that a previously admitted non-citizen seeking adjustment of status must prove admissibility by a preponderance of the evidence, not "clearly and beyond doubt." The petitioner, a Dominican national admitted on a visitor visa in 2000, had her adjustment application denied because a 2013 employment eligibility form had a box checked claiming U.S. citizenship, which she denied checking. The Immigration Judge required proof clearly and beyond doubt that she did not check the box and found the evidence inconclusive, the Board affirmed, and the Fourth Circuit earlier denied review under Chevron deference before the Supreme Court vacated that decision.

The court reasoned that the "clearly and beyond doubt" standard in 8 U.S.C. § 1229a(c)(2)(A) applies to "applicants for admission," and that adjustment is not an admission, citing Bracamontes v. Holder, Azumah v. USCIS, and Aremu v. DHS. Under 8 U.S.C. § 1225(a)(1) and Lopez Garcia v. Guadian, previously admitted adjustment applicants are neither non-citizens who have not been admitted nor those who arrive in the United States, so 8 C.F.R. § 1240.8(b)–(c) does not reach them and § 1240.8(d) supplies the preponderance standard. The court held that the contrary statement in Dakura v. Holder was dicta, since the burden of proof was not at issue there and the claim was undisputed. It remanded without addressing the petitioner's challenges to the admission of the I-9 form or the Immigration Judge's weighing of the evidence.

The full text of Nivar Santana v. Blanche can be found here: https://www.ca4.uscourts.gov/opinions/222114A.p.pdf

Comment