The Board of Immigration Appeals has reversed a grant of protection under the Convention Against Torture to a bisexual Salvadoran with a criminal history and gang tattoos.
“The Immigration Judge did not clearly err in finding that the applicant is a bisexual criminal deportee with visible gang tattoos. Further, the Immigration Judge did not clearly err in finding that if the applicant is removed, he will likely be detained upon his arrival in El Salvador pursuant to the state of exception policy because he will be identified as a suspected gang member deported from the United States with numerous gang-related tattoos and a criminal history. The record establishes that the applicant has a serious criminal history in the United States, and the information about his criminal history would likely be shared with the Salvadoran Government through the Criminal History Information Sharing Program between the United States and El Salvador. Further, the evidence establishes a history of widespread detention of prior and suspected gang members in El Salvador.”
“In finding that the applicant would suffer harm satisfying the definition of torture in detention, the Immigration Judge relied heavily on statistical information and country conditions evidence showing that some detainees and suspected gang members have been subjected to mistreatment, torture, or death while in detention. However, the Immigration Judge relied on a relatively small number of anecdotal incidents of mistreatment or death that fall well short of supporting a clear probability of torture. Overall, out of a total prison population of approximately 95,000 detainees as of November 2022, the Salvadoran Government documented 90 deaths in custody, some of which were attributable to lack of access to medication. Even if the actual number of abuses and deaths is higher than that documented by the Salvadoran Government, the evidence still demonstrates that only a small percentage of detainees died out of the tens of thousands detained.”
“Moreover, the Immigration Judge’s finding that numerous detainees have died in detention does not establish that public officials caused those deaths or that the unspecified human rights abuses rise to the level of torture. The substandard prison conditions referenced by the Immigration Judge, which may include severe overcrowding and lack of food, do not amount to torture as a matter of law unless ‘specifically intended to inflict severe physical or mental pain or suffering.’”
The full text of Matter of A-A-F-V- can be found here: