The Board of Immigration Appeals has denied a motion to reopen filed by a respondent who failed to depart within the voluntary departure period, holding that the ten-year bar on "further relief" under INA § 240B(d)(1)(B), which includes cancellation of removal under INA § 240A(b)(1), applies even where the motion seeks only to submit new evidence on a previously denied cancellation application. A motion to reopen filed before the voluntary departure period expires automatically terminates the grant and its consequences under 8 C.F.R. § 1240.26, but a motion filed after expiration does not change the departure period, and this respondent's motion was filed after the deadline.
The Board rejected the argument that "further relief" covers only new applications, relying on the ordinary meaning of the statute and the fact that the penalties appear in the voluntary departure provision itself. It also noted that Congress created a specific exception for VAWA self-petitioners in INA § 240B(d)(2) and included no comparable exception for reopening, which under the Russello presumption was intentional. In the alternative, the Board found the new evidence supplemental to earlier evidence and unlikely to change the result under Matter of Coelho and Matter of Monreal, since the children would remain in the United States with their mother.
The full text of Matter of Daniel Ontiveros-Diaz can be found here: https://www.justice.gov/eoir/media/1470361/dl?inline