The Board of Immigration Appeals has determined that proffers may be considered in bond proceedings. The Board held that where a party offers an alternative proffer on a material fact or challenges a proffer as uncorroborated or inconsistent with the record, the Immigration Judge should address the challenge and explain in the bond memorandum the weight given to each account. The Board confirmed that under 8 C.F.R. § 1003.19(d) an Immigration Judge may consider "any information," including proffers, but that they must be reliable and probative, and that a facially reliable, undisputed proffer by counsel may be relied on while an unsupported, contested one receives limited weight. The respondent bears the burden under Matter of Guerra, and clear findings are needed for meaningful review under Matter of S-H- and Matter of A-P-.
The Board found the Immigration Judge did not adequately resolve disputed facts about the respondent's claim to have paid taxes since 2012, which was uncorroborated; his vague and inconsistent family ties, including whether his youngest child is a U.S. citizen; and the pending Form I-589, which the judge relied on without a copy or evidence and without addressing how the withholding and CAT claims, which are nondiscretionary and carry a high burden, bear on his incentive to appear. It also found that support statements from his brother and sister-in-law created no enforceable obligation and did not explain how sponsors in Kansas would help him appear in Colorado. On remand, the Immigration Judge must resolve the disputed facts and decide whether he has shown he is not a flight risk.
The full text of Matter of G-M-T- can be found here: https://www.justice.gov/eoir/media/1471311/dl?inline