The Board of Immigration Appeals has determined that "Guatemalan women without partners" is not a cognizable particular social group. Applying Matter of M-E-V-G-, the Board found the group lacks particularity because "partner" has no clear boundaries and could mean anything from casual dating to marriage, and found no evidence of social distinction, which is measured countrywide under Matter of S-E-M-Z-. Following Matter of K-E-S-G-, it also noted that a group defined by sex or sex and nationality alone is overbroad.

The Board further held that the Immigration Judge clearly erred in finding an imputed political opinion. The record did not show that the harassers knew the respondent was walking to school or viewed her conduct through a political lens, and even if they saw it as defiance of male-dominated norms, that would not be a political opinion. Under Matter of D-G-E-A- & N-G-G-E-, a political opinion must be tied to a belief about a discrete cause related to the government. The Board declined to follow the Second Circuit's Hernandez-Chacon v. Barr because it is not binding in the Third Circuit, where the case arose. With no cognizable group or political-opinion nexus, the respondent did not show harm on account of a protected ground, and the Board ordered her removed to Guatemala.

The full text of Matter of A-C-V-M- can be found here: https://www.justice.gov/eoir/media/1471516/dl?inline

Comment